Crosstie Flexural Comparison

The present research seeks to compare the flexural behavior of different crosstie technologies with a goal of understanding the similarities and differences in flexural behavior. Commercially produced wood, composite, and concrete crossties are tested in center negative and rail-seat positive flexure as described in AREMA Chapter 40 and the relative flexural performances are compared. Unsurprisingly, wood and composite ties have lower bending stiffness and somewhat lower strength while demonstrating greater deflection capability. The observations obtained in this testing help to quantify the relative structural contribution of the differing tie technologies and may indicate that required flexural capacity for concrete ties should be assessed on the basis of deflection rather than load. Accordingly, we suggest further research into concrete tie design paradigms that prioritize deflection performance which we believe will lead to robust performance and long service life.

National University Rail Center of Excellence
1239B Newmark Civil Engineering Laboratory, MC-250
205 N Mathews Avenue
Urbana, IL 61801
(217) 300-1340